|
|
Hi Newsletter Subscribers,
|
|
|
|
|
|
If you've ever posted a #beaguest post in the group, checked back later, and seen… nothing — you're not alone.
In fact, that's the most common outcome.
Most #beaguest posts get:
👀 a few views
💬 zero or one comment
🤷♀️ and then quietly disappear down the feed
Five to ten comments is already a win.
Anything more than that is genuinely out of the ordinary.
That doesn't mean your post was bad.
It means you're operating in a very crowded room — and understanding how people actually use this space matters more than posting louder or more often.
So this week, we want to zoom out and look at the full dynamic — guest posts and host posts — based on what we consistently see working inside the group.
|
|
|
|
🔍 A key distinction that explains almost everything
|
|
|
|
#findaguest and #beaguest posts behave very differently — and for good reason.
When someone posts #findaguest, they already have intent:
🎯 they're actively looking
🧠 they're comparing replies
📋 they're filtering for fit
That's why topic alignment alone can drive strong engagement there.
But here's the part people don't talk about enough:
👉 Hundreds of comments on a #findaguest post isn't always a good thing.
From the host's side, it often means:
😵 overwhelm
⏳ too much to read
🤯 decision paralysis
The best #findaguest posts aren't the ones that attract everyone — they're the ones that attract the right 10–30 people.
Clear scope beats raw volume every time.
|
|
|
|
🧠 What strong #findaguest posts do well
|
|
|
|
The host posts that consistently perform well (without becoming unmanageable) usually share a few traits:
✨ They clearly define the type of guest they want
✨ They name the topic or conversation style upfront
✨ They subtly discourage poor fits
This doesn't reduce engagement — it improves signal.
Fewer comments, better matches, easier follow-up.
That's not accidental.
That's design.
|
|
|
|
🔁 Now let's talk about #beaguest posts (and why they struggle)
|
|
|
|
With #beaguest posts, the dynamic flips completely.
Hosts are:
📱 scrolling quickly
👀 skimming, not reading deeply
⚖️ making snap judgments about relevance
So the question usually isn't:
“Is this a good guest?”
It's:
“Is this for me, right now?”
If that answer isn't obvious almost immediately, the scroll continues.
That's why #beaguest is harder — not because guests aren't good, but because attention is fragmented.
|
|
|
|
✨ What the better-performing #beaguest posts actually do
|
|
|
|
The guest posts that do get traction — even modest, healthy traction — tend to be very legible.
They don't try to appeal to everyone.
They don't oversell themselves.
And they don't make the host work to understand them.
Instead, they make three things clear fast:
✨ What the conversation is really about
Not “I help people,” but something a host can imagine in their feed.
✨ Who it's best for
Strong posts often name a specific audience or context. Fewer replies isn't failure — it's filtering.
✨ Why this will be easy
Experience, structure, or simply showing you've done this before signals safety:
👉 This won't be work.
This is also why some longer posts outperform short ones — not because they're long, but because they're organized the way hosts already think.
|
|
|
|
🔄 A strategy shift many guests miss
|
|
|
|
Here's the part we really want to underline:
👉 Posting #beaguest is only one way to get booked.
And often, it's not the easiest one.
Because #findaguest posts already have intent, many guests do better by:
👀 watching the feed
🎯 waiting for aligned #findaguest posts
✍️ responding thoughtfully when there's a clear match
In other words:
Instead of standing in the crowd saying “pick me,”
you're answering a specific invitation.
That dynamic is often calmer, clearer, and more human — for everyone involved.
|
|
|
|
📉 One last reframe that helps a lot
|
|
|
|
Low comment count doesn't mean your post failed.
One reply from the right host is worth far more than:
❌ ten vague “interested!” comments
❌ mismatched conversations
❌ bookings that go nowhere
Many hosts don't comment at all.
They:
🔖 save posts
👤 click profiles
🕰️ come back later
Silence usually means “not a fit,” not “not good.”
And that's okay.
|
|
|
|
|
<!--[if mso | IE]>
<![endif]--> |
|
|
|
💛 What we hope you take from this
|
|
|
|
Nothing is “wrong” with you.
Nothing is “broken” about the group.
You're participating in a space where:
✨ clarity beats volume
✨ specificity beats reach
✨ alignment beats noise
Whether you're posting #findaguest, #beaguest, or quietly responding in comments — understanding the flow of the room makes everything easier.
Happy Collaborating,
__
The Podcast Collaborative Team
P.S. If there's interest, next week we can break this down even further — including how hosts quietly shortlist guests, and how guests can spot high-intent posts early before they fill up. Or we can take any other direction…
Just say the word.
Ready to ride the wave of podcasting's biggest year yet?Come check out the Podcast Collab Club and connect with creators who are making it happen!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ready to start taking the guesswork out of finding great guests and the legwork out of landing aligned interviews?
|
|
|
|
|
The Podcast Collaborative
Mansfield, CT 06268, USA
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
