A Year of Bach
A Year of Bach
Podcast Description
Bach is the greatest, and we still don’t talk about him enough. A Year of Bach extends my year-long listening project into conversation. I sit down with writers, philosophers, economists, and entrepreneurs to ask how this 300-year-old music continually rewrites us.
Subscribe here: https://yearofbach.substack.com/ yearofbach.substack.com
Podcast Insights
Content Themes
The podcast explores the themes of music's emotional impact, personal connections to Bach, and the intersection of literature and music, with episodes discussing topics such as the 'expectation of astonishment' in music and the significance of late bloomers in the arts, as highlighted in the debut episode featuring Henry Oliver.

Bach is the greatest, and we still don’t talk about him enough. A Year of Bach extends my year-long listening project into conversation. I sit down with writers, philosophers, economists, and entrepreneurs to ask how this 300-year-old music continually rewrites us.
Subscribe here: https://yearofbach.substack.com/
A conversation with political philosopher Rebecca Lowe (The Ends Don’t Justify the Means) about objectivity and musical beauty, the differences between American and British choral singing, and her skepticism about historically-informed performance. Lowe shares favorite Bach works (the E minor flute sonata, the “Great” G minor organ fugue) and her broader musical tastes including Britten, Strauss, Mozart, opera, Stevie Wonder, Chet Baker, and Angela Hewitt.
Albums discussed:
Angela Hewitt, Bach: The Art of Fugue (Hyperion, 2014)Spotify · Apple Music · YouTube
Emmanuel Pahud and Trevor Pinnock, Bach: Complete Flute Sonatas (2008), which opens with the E minor sonata, BWV 1034Spotify · Apple Music · YouTube
Emmanuel Pahud and Stephen Kovacevich, Pahud plays Debussy, Ravel & ProkofievSpotify · Apple Music · YouTube
Glenn Gould, A Consort of Musicke Bye William Byrde and Orlando GibbonsSpotify · Apple Music · YouTube
Gerald Finley and Julius Drake, Barber songsSpotify · Apple Music · YouTube
Karl Richter, Bach cantatasSpotify · Apple Music · YouTube
Transcript:
[00:00:00]
Evan Goldfine: Hello, and welcome to A Year of Bach. My name is Evan Goldfine, and today my guest is Rebecca Lowe, a political philosopher whose work centers on freedom, rights, and equality. She’s currently a philosophy senior research fellow at the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, and her excellent Substack is called The Ends Don’t Justify the Means, where she warns about the troubles of consequentialism in a genial way.
Rebecca came to philosophy after earning a degree of music at Cambridge, so today we’ll talk about the different pleasures of philosophy and music, and also plenty about Bach. I’ve asked Rebecca to bring her strongest-held opinions, and perhaps if we’re lucky, we’ll see how we’re frustrated by each other’s tastes.
Rebecca, welcome.
Rebecca Lowe: Hey, thanks so much for having me, Evan. I’m excited about this.
Evan Goldfine: So I wanted to start with a little praise for your writing and podcasting. I find your prose to be very lively and bouncy while engaging with deep and sometimes troubling subjects. It’s sort of an interesting strategy about keeping [00:01:00] discussions engaging.
I sense you also take a lot of joy in the philosophical argument. Am I onto something here? Does it echo with your enjoyment of music? How did you get your voice?
Rebecca Lowe: Oh gosh. I mean, that’s a big question, isn’t it? So I grew up in a family of philosophers. Both my parents are philosophers, so I think philosophical argument is something that I just imbibed.
I was talking to a friend, in fact, our mutual friend, Henry Oliver, about this yesterday, and about the idea of how you learn how to do philosophical talking, philosophical arguing, and I think even though the content of a lot of the conversations I had at home growing up was philosophy, I think even if that hadn’t been the case, I think I would’ve had a childhood full of philosophy because the ways in which my parents talk and the ways in which I talk are very philosophy imbued.
One of my close friends one time made this joke. She was introducing me to someone, and she said, “Hey, this is my friend Rebecca, [00:02:00] who likes to start her sentences, ‘It is the case that…’” And this just summarizes me very well. So I think I have a way of talking which is broadly the way in which philosophers write, and I think beyond that, though, I am very keen to make philosophy intelligible to people who don’t know about philosophy.
I like very plain, straight, dry prose. I’m one of these people who loves, for instance, American novelists and American philosophers who other people find to be overly nitpicky and very, very plain in their writing. I’m probably the only person in the world who thinks John Rawls is a beautiful writer.
But I do attempt, at least when I’m writing philosophy, to write it how I talk. So I’ve already ruined that by saying I talk in a philosophical way, but the best bit of advice I was given about writing was from my supervisor at Cambridge, who’s one of my favorite people, and we can talk about him a little maybe, ‘cause he was a great musician.
But he one time told me, “Just read out everything that you write.”
[00:03:00] And I think this is the best advice you can give to someone who wants their writing to be more understandable.
Evan Goldfine: Yeah. So how did that philosophical house be filled with music? Were your parents also musicians? You ended up pursuing music before a proper philosophy degree.
What’s your origin?
Rebecca Lowe: This is a good question. My dad was very musical. He taught me how to read music and play the recorder. He also had a flute that a friend of his had given to him and he’d never really played, which I think was the main reason for me starting to play the flute. My grandparents had a piano.
We used to go visit them every other weekend. I was obsessed by playing the piano. My mom’s probably will listen to this, my dad sadly isn’t alive anymore. But my mom will probably listen to this. She may disagree with this, but I actually think I was really the only person in the household who regularly listened to music.
Both my parents loved classical music, but I was obsessed by listening to this stuff from a very young [00:04:00] age. We had some very good audio cassettes. My grandmother, like I say, she was a very good pianist. So music was around, but I do think, and I’ll probably say this as some kind of individualist, I think it was also my own driving of my interest.
Evan Goldfine: What hit you early on, as apart from your siblings or your parents?
Rebecca Lowe: I think yeah, my brother. He hit me early on.
Evan Goldfine: In a different way.
Rebecca Lowe: Yeah. I think some of the earliest things I can remember listening to, we had a very good, I totally forgot this until you mentioned it, actually. We had a very nice recording of the Carnival of the Animals.
And I really liked the colorful ways in which animals were depicted. I’ve gone on to have a bit of a philosophical interest in this idea of what music can depict. And actually, yes, so I did, my undergrad is in music at Cambridge, which is the worst place to go if you wanna do performance.
Although being a performing musician in Cambridge is amazing. You have endless resources and opportunities to make music with wonderful musicians. [00:05:00] But the music degree is not any performance at all. It’s entirely applied math, basically, as the Americans say. It’s very much analysis. You don’t listen to any music in any of your lectures.
If you’re doing any composition, it’s in order to show analytical skill, not to actually express yourself through composition. The thing I was interested in was really aesthetics, so the philosophy of art, with a particular focus on music. I did get to do some of that in my second and third years, but I found it very… I mean, I like math, but I was not intending to do a math degree, and doing music at Cambridge was effectively doing that.
I think it made me into a better musician. I think it made me a more rigorous thinker. I was already good at writing arguments, but I think this helped me in various ways. But it’s a bit of a funny thing to have done, I think. It has abstract value, and I think being excellent at anything has application value, but-
Evan Goldfine: So you learned your voice leading, you learned your counterpoint, you could write [00:06:00] according to the rules that Bach created. But did you create anything that was meaningful?
Rebecca Lowe: No. So I was thinking about this. I don’t know what your view is on this. Over the past few weeks I see people tweeting about these AI created Bach chorales and Bach fugues. I haven’t looked at the fugues, but I had a very, very quick look at one of the chorales that everyone was lauding as this perfect, beautiful bit of voice leading, and it’s absolutely dreadful.
I mean, there were parallels in the first bar.
And I’m like, the problem, because I had this, you kno…
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit yearofbach.substack.com

Disclaimer
This podcast’s information is provided for general reference and was obtained from publicly accessible sources. The Podcast Collaborative neither produces nor verifies the content, accuracy, or suitability of this podcast. Views and opinions belong solely to the podcast creators and guests.
For a complete disclaimer, please see our Full Disclaimer on the archive page. The Podcast Collaborative bears no responsibility for the podcast’s themes, language, or overall content. Listener discretion is advised. Read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy for more details.