Ontario Cold Cases – The Podcast
Ontario Cold Cases - The Podcast
Podcast Description
Explore the unsolved mysteries of Ontario, Canada with our captivating true crime podcast, Ontario Cold Cases - The Podcast. Join our team of dedicated detectives from Nicoll Investigations as they investigate cold cases, homicides, missing persons, and other crimes, all across Canada. Delve into forgotten crimes and help us remember the victims and bring justice and hopefully peace, to the families. Tune in to our engaging exploration of unsolved mysteries today and discover the chilling stories that deserve to be remembered! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Podcast Insights
Content Themes
The podcast delves into a variety of content themes related to true crime, focusing on cold cases, unsolved murders, and significant criminal investigations. Some highlighted episodes include the Gardner Museum Heist, exploring a massive art theft, and ‘The Enduring Mystery of Mistie Murray,’ which investigates the disappearance of a teen in Goderich, Ontario.

Explore the unsolved mysteries of Ontario, Canada with our captivating true crime podcast, Ontario Cold Cases – The Podcast. Join our team of dedicated detectives from Nicoll Investigations as they investigate cold cases, homicides, missing persons, and other crimes, all across Canada. Delve into forgotten crimes and help us remember the victims and bring justice and hopefully peace, to the families. Tune in to our engaging exploration of unsolved mysteries today and discover the chilling stories that deserve to be remembered!
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Justin Pollari: The Night He Vanished
How does a fourteen-year-old boy vanish off an island?
Justin ”Woody” Pollari was 14 when he disappeared from Hilton Beach, St. Joseph Island, Ontario, on Friday, December 7, 2001. He went to a community gathering at the Hilton Beach Community Hall with his friends. He was driven home later that evening. And after that, nobody saw him again.
He left everything behind — his clothes, his money, and the skateboard that never left his side. That's not a runaway.
Almost immediately, the Ontario Provincial Police classified him as a runaway. The case was reopened in 2005 and again in 2018. Both times, no findings. Teenagers who were there that night tried to tell the police what they had seen. They were dismissed, and their accounts never made it into any official investigation.
In this episode, private investigator Jay Nicoll — working on behalf of Justin's mother, Lori Smith — opens the case: the night Justin vanished, the island he vanished from, the single word that shaped everything that came after, and the new investigation that has now spoken to more than sixty witnesses and is preparing a formal submission to the East Algoma OPP.
If you know something about Justin Pollari, contact Jay directly at [email protected] or 289-923-7302 — anonymity respected. Or stay anonymous through Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-TIPS. OPP case reference: RM01176313. Help continue the investigation: https://gofund.me/53fb353a4
Jay Nicoll is a licensed private investigator (Nicoll Investigations, Richmond Hill, Ontario) and host of Ontario Cold Cases – Canada's True Crime Podcast. Allegations referenced are under investigation and are not findings of fact.
Because every case deserves answers—and every victim deserves justice.
#JustinPollari, #ColdCase, #Ontario, #StJosephIsland,#NicollInvestigations, #OntarioColdCases, #SaultSteMarie, #CanadianTrueCrime,
Please consider subscribing to Ontario Cold Cases – Canada's True Crime Podcast available everywhere you get your podcasts.
Show notes links:
– Investigation fund: https://gofund.me/53fb353a4
– Direct contact: [email protected] · 289-923-7302 · anonymity respected
– Anonymous tips: Crime Stoppers 1-800-222-TIPS
– OPP: 1-877-934-6363 (case RM01176313)
– Nicoll Investigations: https://www.nicollinvestigations.ca/
Sources:
– Canada's Missing (RCMP), case file for Justin Jonathan Robert Pollari — https://www.services.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/missing-disparus/case-dossier.jsf?case=2006011699&id=0
– Nicoll Investigations, ”The Skateboard Stayed Behind: Reconstructing Justin Pollari's Last Night, 25 Years Later,” Substack, July 2026 — https://ontariocoldcase.substack.com/p/the-skateboard-stayed-behind-reconstructing
– Nicoll Investigations, ”Justin Pollari — 14 years old, missing from St. Joseph Island Ontario since Dec 7 2001,” Substack, June 2026 — https://ontariocoldcase.substack.com/p/justin-pollari-14-years-old-missing
– Nicoll Investigations case file, 2026 — 60+ witness interviews, Tip and Witness Contact Register, formal submission to East Algoma OPP in preparation (no link)
– OPP case reference RM01176313 (no link)
– Investigation fund: https://gofund.me/53fb353a4
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Disclaimer
This podcast’s information is provided for general reference and was obtained from publicly accessible sources. The Podcast Collaborative neither produces nor verifies the content, accuracy, or suitability of this podcast. Views and opinions belong solely to the podcast creators and guests.
For a complete disclaimer, please see our Full Disclaimer on the archive page. The Podcast Collaborative bears no responsibility for the podcast’s themes, language, or overall content. Listener discretion is advised. Read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy for more details.