Behind the Badge with Garry McCarthy

Behind the Badge with Garry McCarthy
Podcast Description
In "Behind the Badge," former Chicago top cop Garry McCarthy offers a rare look into the inner workings of one of America’s most-scrutinized police forces. Beyond breaking down the latest crime trends and the policies that shape strategies, McCarthy and seasoned law enforcement officials share what it really means to wear the badge—revealing both the challenges and rewards of serving on the front lines.
Podcast Insights
Content Themes
The podcast focuses on law enforcement experiences, crime trends, and the emotional impact of policing, with episodes covering topics like the camaraderie among officers in the NYPD football team and the personal stories of families coping with police-related trauma, exemplified by the episode featuring the memories of Officer Ella French.

In “Wearing the Badge,” former Chicago top cop Garry McCarthy offers a rare look into the inner workings of one of America’s most-scrutinized police forces. Beyond breaking down the latest crime trends and the policies that shape strategies, McCarthy and seasoned law enforcement officials share what it really means to wear the badge—revealing both the challenges and rewards of serving on the front lines.
In the second episode of our three‑part SAFE‑T Act series, Illinois House Speaker Pro Tempore Representative Kam Buckner and State Senator John Curran join the conversation—bringing perspectives from both sides of the General Assembly. They discuss how the bill was crafted without meaningful input from local law enforcement, the shift from reactive to proactive policing by blending data-driven models with broken‑windows theory, and the lessons learned from police chiefs across the country. They also unpack the behind‑the‑scenes political currents that shape policing in ways the public rarely sees, the urgency to act following high‑profile tragedies like George Floyd and Laquan McDonald, and the debate over wise versus wasteful use of police resources—especially given Chicago’s unique history and violence patterns. This episode pulls back the curtain on policy-making, giving you a legislative lens on the public safety reforms sweeping Illinois.
00:00 Introduction
01:20 Between Two Linebackers
03:00 Who is John Curran?
05:27 Who is Kam Buckner?
09:07 Telling Cops How to Do Their Jobs
10:43 Who Wrote the SAFE-T Act?
14:56 Reactive Policing to Proactive Policing
18:00 Ron Serpas and Data-Driven Policing
19:15 “Doing Something” After George Floyd
20:58 Learning from Other Chiefs
23:20 Policing Gang Activity
25:05 Abandoning Winning Strategies
26:10 Experts Versus Politicians
27:40 How Do We Move Forward?
30:21 The Three Kinds of Police
31:28 Dispatching and the Clean Screen
32:02 Using Cops Wisely
34:15 Laquan McDonald and George Floyd
37:15 Miranda Rights Were “Radical” Too
38:22 Half Cop/Half Egghead
39:11 Collaboration and Deadlines
40:24 Pre-trial Fairness Act
42:26 Learning from Scandals
45:01 Overlooking Black on Black Crime
46:18 Chicago’s History of Violence
48:10 Cops are Human
49:58 Executing the Law
51:52 Suggested Fixes
52:52 Felony Murder
56:10 Conclusion
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Disclaimer
This podcast’s information is provided for general reference and was obtained from publicly accessible sources. The Podcast Collaborative neither produces nor verifies the content, accuracy, or suitability of this podcast. Views and opinions belong solely to the podcast creators and guests.
For a complete disclaimer, please see our Full Disclaimer on the archive page. The Podcast Collaborative bears no responsibility for the podcast’s themes, language, or overall content. Listener discretion is advised. Read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy for more details.