Story Deep Dive Podcast
Story Deep Dive Podcast
Podcast Description
Join editor and USA Today bestselling author Dana Pittman and developmental editor Rachel Arsenault for a weekly deep dive into great novels. storydeepdive.substack.com
Podcast Insights
Content Themes
The show emphasizes a range of topics within literature, focusing primarily on plot structure, character development, and writing techniques. Examples include their episode deep dives into the character journey in Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo and the dynamics of humor in Things We Never Got Over. Additionally, they explore how themes like power, community, and emotional healing are presented across genres.

Join editor and USA Today bestselling author Dana Pittman and developmental editor Rachel Arsenault for a weekly deep dive into great novels.
Welcome to Story Deep Dive!
In this episode, Dana and Rachel wrap their month on The Christmas Fix by Lucy Score with their editor’s takeaways: why this early holiday romance is worth handing to a client, rough spots and all, and what it shows about making a story yours.
Whether you’re a romance writer, paranormal author, or story strategist, you’ll gain valuable insights on making a holiday matter to your characters, choosing which moments to expand on the page, and trusting the voice that’s already in your early work.
You can also watch the video version of this podcast on YouTube!
Estimate Timestamps
0:27 – December Preview: The Best Of
Rachel tees up December’s best-of episodes, where each host picks two favorites from the year. Narrowing it to one “feels cruel and unusual,” and Rachel is ready to force her favorites to duke it out.
2:24 – How Rachel Picks
Rachel skips the obvious all-time favorites and looks for the books that brought something new or sparked the best discussion. Her Notion tracker holds every book, recording date and note. Dana’s paper notes are “somewhere in outer space.”
5:41 – Hell Bent, Spinning Silver, and Sharp Objects
Dana stayed up until 2:30 a.m. to finish Hell Bent and texted Rachel the moment she was done. She also reveals Spinning Silver is headed to her book club next year, once she understood “the container.” Sharp Objects was the one pick that was “not my bag at all,” and Dana explains why a book club is still worth it for the books you don’t love.
20:07 – The Agenda
Dana comes at the takeaways from a new angle: why she’d hand this book to a client. Rachel brings expanding and collapsing time, building the relationship in every shared scene, and what early Lucy Score teaches after Things We Never Got Over.
24:05 – A Demonstrative Book
Dana calls this a demonstration of a true holiday romance, a low stakes romance, and a small town romance “where the town is a character, not just a small town in geography.” She contrasts it with Louisiana Longshot and Knockemout to show another way to use setting beyond location.
26:43 – Make the Holiday Personal
Christmas is more than the ticking clock here. Dana: Score “made that holiday special,” to Noah and to the town of Merry, and that “gave it depth to the stakes even though it was low stakes.”
28:31 – The Chiropractic Adjustment
Rachel on summary as an opportunity: Score filters the passage of time through plot-relevant details. Her bigger point: “If you can motivate it with the plot, the audience will follow you there.” All your favorite scene needs is “a chiropractic adjustment to put it in line with your plot.”
34:26 – Layers With a Light Hand
Noah has a lot going on, and Score keeps it present without letting it take over. Dana: “In romance, you go too deep in one, you’re changing subcategories.” You can write complex characters “while still treating it with a light hand so that it doesn’t cause the story to go left.”
36:31 – Every Shared Scene Is an Opportunity
Rachel: “Every opportunity your characters are together is an opportunity to further develop that relationship.” Seeing Noah with his daughter, or Cat with her production team, changes how the other lead and the reader see them. Dana adds intentional POV choices and the humor that diffuses tense moments.
41:19 – The Kernel of Your Superpower
Rachel has found it “100% of the time”: an author’s early book already holds the thing that makes their work theirs. Dana on what that becomes over time: “That’s not a genre. It’s not a niche. It’s a person. It’s her DNA.”
45:26 – Your Reading Assignment
Rachel’s challenge: read The Christmas Fix, listen to this month’s episodes, then read Things We Never Got Over to see where the craft concepts click.
47:27 – The Squishy Parts
Dana names what didn’t land: “This breakup scene needs some help,” and the external thread never put Christmas in jeopardy. She still recommends the book.
50:27 – Impact Over Perfection
Dana’s closer: “You don’t need it to be perfect for it to be a great story.” You close the book, exhale, and say, “that was good.”
Book Selection:
Title: The Christmas Fix
Author: Lucy Score
She’ll save Christmas just to spite him…
There’s only one thing standing in the way of Cat King saving a small town’s Christmas festival: Grumpy town manager Noah Yates.
Single dad Noah takes his responsibilities seriously. When a late season hurricane turns Merry, Connecticut, into a disaster, he’s left scrambling to pick up the pieces of the town he loves.
At least, until home renovation expert and smoking hot reality TV star Catalina King arrives with a camera crew and a budget big enough to put the town back together again. But Noah doesn’t want a celebrity diva capitalizing on their tragedy or filling his daughter’s head with visions of glitz and glam.
Blonde bombshell Cat is used to being underestimated, but Noah has an uncanny knack for getting under her skin. They can’t be in a room together without rubbing each other the wrong way…except that time in the dark alley where the rubbing was just right. Can these enemies work together to pull off a Christmas miracle or will their fighting leave them both on the naughty list?
Where to Find the Book
The Christmas Fix by Lucy Score is available in several formats. It’s also widely available in libraries and online retailers. Details on her website.
Next Episode:
In the next episode, Dana and Rachel are back with a bonus episode. Then in December, they look back at the year’s books, pick their favorites, and finally get to talk spoilers.
Join the Conversation:
Like what you heard? Subscribe, leave a review, and share your thoughts at storydeepdive.com. Follow Story Deep Dive on YouTube and Substack, and connect with Dana and Rachel to keep the discussion going!
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit storydeepdive.substack.com

Disclaimer
This podcast’s information is provided for general reference and was obtained from publicly accessible sources. The Podcast Collaborative neither produces nor verifies the content, accuracy, or suitability of this podcast. Views and opinions belong solely to the podcast creators and guests.
For a complete disclaimer, please see our Full Disclaimer on the archive page. The Podcast Collaborative bears no responsibility for the podcast’s themes, language, or overall content. Listener discretion is advised. Read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy for more details.