Welcome to Story Deep Dive!

In this episode, Dana and Rachel kick off their new four-part series on Cold and Deadly by Toni Anderson with a preview episode that blends personal updates, genre analysis, and a thoughtful breakdown of how romance, suspense, and mystery intersect.

Whether you’re a writer, reader, or storytelling enthusiast, you’ll gain valuable insights on navigating genre mashups, crafting slow burn romance, and setting clear expectations for your audience.

You can also watch the video version of this podcast on YouTube!

Estimate Timestamps

00:00 – Intro & Twitch Talk: Horror as Immersive Storytelling

Rachel shares her intense experience live-streaming the horror game SOMA on Twitch, reflecting on how interactive media generates emotional and physical responses. Dana draws parallels between gaming, storytelling, and the importance of curating audience experiences across mediums.

12:30 – Creative Platforms & Monetization

Dana and Rachel unpack the shifting dynamics between Twitch and YouTube, exploring monetization, content moderation, and live streaming trends for creators. They highlight how different mediums shape the way stories are told and experienced.

18:30 – Bootcamp Updates & Netflix’s Genre Failures

Dana updates listeners on the Romance Writers Bootcamp. Then, the hosts critique a Netflix adaptation that posed as a romance but failed to deliver an HEA, using it as a launchpad to discuss the importance of honoring genre norms.

27:15 – Romance vs. Love Story: A Crucial Distinction

Rachel and Dana dive deep into the difference between romance and tragic love stories, emphasizing why mislabeled genre stories frustrate readers. They advocate for clear marketing and genre integrity to respect audience trust.

33:30 – Thriller vs. Suspense: How to Define the Experience

Rachel offers her definitions: suspense = antagonist hunts protagonist; thriller = protagonist hunts antagonist. Dana shares her own take and how romantic suspense often blurs these lines. They agree the most important factor is setting and fulfilling the reader’s expectations.

47:00 – Genre Blending in Romance Writing

They discuss how romantic suspense authors can borrow from thriller, mystery, and action genres—without confusing or alienating readers. Clear author intention and consistent brand language are key to pulling it off.

55:45 – What Counts as Slow Burn Today?

The hosts analyze Cold and Deadly‘s slow burn romance. With no on-page intimacy until halfway through the book, it bucks current pacing trends—but succeeds thanks to its grounded emotional stakes, forced proximity, and character-driven tension.

1:06:00 – Romantic Intention & Chemistry Clues

Dana explains how even slow burns require early romantic cues. Rachel praises how Anderson gradually increases the sensual tone throughout the book, allowing the relationship to feel both earned and believable.

1:13:00 – Writing for Escapism & Fantasy Fulfillment

They remind writers that attraction and chemistry are part of the fantasy readers crave. Even in serious or emotional stories, physical connection helps fulfill romance expectations.

1:20:30 – Layered Characters: A Case Study in Craft

Cold and Deadly features deeply layered characters with emotional wounds, professional conflicts, and family backstory. Dana and Rachel note how the internal arcs are well balanced for a single-book structure, including the antagonist’s depth.

1:26:00 – Final Thoughts & What’s Ahead

The hosts wrap with praise for the book’s pacing, genre execution, and emotional payoff. They highlight its value as a teaching tool for writers across genres and tease upcoming deep dives into specific craft elements.

Book Selection

About Cold & Deadly…

FBI Crisis Negotiator Dominic Sheridan is adept at dealing with high-stake situations under treacherous conditions. But nothing prepared him for the headstrong rookie agent, Ava Kanas, who seems hell-bent on destroying her fledgling career while in pursuit of justice.

When several agents die in quick succession it becomes obvious a killer is targeting the FBI, and Dominic in particular. Together, Dominic and Ava race to find the murderer, all the while fighting a forbidden attraction that will complicate everything, especially when a predator has them in their sights.

Where to Find the Book

Cold & Deadly by Toni Anderson is available in several formats. It’s also widely available in libraries and online retailers. Details on the author’s website.

Next Episode:

In the next episode, Dana and Rachel shift focus to the romantic structure and slow-burn execution in Cold and Deadly, exploring how Toni Anderson paces attraction, tension, and emotional vulnerability to create a deeply satisfying romance.

Join the Conversation:

Like what you heard? Subscribe, leave a review, and share your thoughts! Follow Story Deep Dive on your favorite platforms and connect with Dana and Rachel to keep the discussion going!

Connect with Rachel and Dana at www.storydeepdive.com to keep the discussion going!

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit storydeepdive.substack.com