Reimagining Us
Reimagining Us
Podcast Description
Reimagining Us is not just another conversation series—it’s a vital tool for healing divisions, designing our lives and communities for belonging, and empowering a movement of “builders.” Hosted by two distinguished leaders from the fields of psychology and equity-building, the show takes a nuanced look at the forces that fuel division and highlights actionable paths toward reconnection. As the nation navigates a post-election landscape rife with challenges, Reimagining Us offers a timely and necessary space for discovery, dialogue, and change.
Throughout America, our neighborhoods and local communities find themselves at an unprecedented moment. Pundits and political leaders roil us in toxically polarized, "us vs. them" narratives. In many places, our communities are marked by mistrust, fear of or inability to engage neighbors across differences, and loneliness & isolation.
What can make us resilient? The answer is easy but profound: Each other. Our communities thrive when they are places of belonging for all. It’s time to rebuild the “we” – a bigger sense of “we” than what we see around us today. And no moment could be more critical to do this than now: Regardless who emerges victorious in November, half the country will feel left behind, or worse, betrayed.
Local communities are the life force of democracy, but belonging doesn’t just happen by default. The way for folks to begin to imagine a feasible/fair future is to begin to experience themselves as mattering, as belonging in their communities, now – in their families, their neighborhoods, their grocery stores, their town halls, in all aspects of their daily lives. And we’re not talking about being “nice” or polite. We–all of us— need to design our lives and communities for belonging, to be intentional about how we show up, and how we create spaces for others to show up—both through our interactions and the structures and systems we put in place. And we need to start at home, in our communities.
HOSTS:
Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of TogetherUp Institute
Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum
Produced by Next Chapter Podcasts
Podcast Insights
Content Themes
The podcast explores themes related to community building, social resilience, and the dynamics of belonging versus othering, with episodes addressing timely topics such as the Needham Resilience Network's collaboration efforts and the importance of civic infrastructure in revitalizing local relationships. Specific episodes dissect actionable strategies for engaging across differences, navigating toxic polarization, and understanding the role of storytelling in promoting inclusivity.

Reimagining Us is not just another conversation series—it’s a vital tool for healing divisions, designing our lives and communities for belonging, and empowering a movement of “builders.” Hosted by two distinguished leaders from the fields of psychology and equity-building, the show takes a nuanced look at the forces that fuel division and highlights actionable paths toward reconnection. As the nation navigates a post-election landscape rife with challenges, Reimagining Us offers a timely and necessary space for discovery, dialogue, and change.
Throughout America, our neighborhoods and local communities find themselves at an unprecedented moment. Pundits and political leaders roil us in toxically polarized, “us vs. them” narratives. In many places, our communities are marked by mistrust, fear of or inability to engage neighbors across differences, and loneliness & isolation.
What can make us resilient? The answer is easy but profound: Each other. Our communities thrive when they are places of belonging for all. It’s time to rebuild the “we” – a bigger sense of “we” than what we see around us today. And no moment could be more critical to do this than now: Regardless who emerges victorious in November, half the country will feel left behind, or worse, betrayed.
Local communities are the life force of democracy, but belonging doesn’t just happen by default. The way for folks to begin to imagine a feasible/fair future is to begin to experience themselves as mattering, as belonging in their communities, now – in their families, their neighborhoods, their grocery stores, their town halls, in all aspects of their daily lives. And we’re not talking about being “nice” or polite. We–all of us— need to design our lives and communities for belonging, to be intentional about how we show up, and how we create spaces for others to show up—both through our interactions and the structures and systems we put in place. And we need to start at home, in our communities.
HOSTS:
Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of TogetherUp Institute
Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum
Produced by Next Chapter Podcasts
The election is behind us, but the patterns that wear us down haven’t gone anywhere: the outrage, the scorekeeping, the feeling of watching from the sidelines. Nearly two-thirds of Americans report feeling exhausted when they think about politics. But exhaustion isn’t apathy. People can care deeply about their communities while feeling worn down by the constant conflict and the doubt that anything they do will matter. And the people who could change those patterns often aren’t the loudest voices. They’re the ones who’ve quietly stepped back.
In this episode of Reimagining Us, Dr. Nichole Argo and Scott Hutcheson explore the distance between wanting things to get better and believing we can help make it happen. Stephen Hawkins, Global Director of Research at More in Common and lead author of Hidden Tribes, the study that coined the term “the exhausted majority,” explains why politics has become the hardest divide for Americans to cross. People see the value in connecting, but often feel they lack the energy, or the opportunity, to try. He shares his own journey from College Republican to progressive activist to feeling “a little bit politically homeless.”
Part of the answer may be in the invitation. Few people are eager to sit down and discuss group tensions. Many more would welcome the chance to work with someone different on something that improves their community. As Scott puts it, people will help after a hurricane more readily than they’ll attend a polarization workshop.
And sometimes, stepping back has more to do with exclusion than exhaustion. People can experience the same city differently. For instance, in Lexington, Kentucky, about half of white residents say they truly belong, compared with 1 in 5 residents of color. And nearly 8 in 10 residents, across demographic groups, believe some voices count more than others. Addressing those inequalities and helping people understand one another are both essential parts of building a community people want to join.
What can that look like? John Sarrouf of Essential Partners recalls sitting down with members of a local Rod and Gun Club who walked in deeply suspicious. He brought pizza and asked them to tell him about their first gun. An hour in, a woman who had insisted you can’t talk to the other side asked whether they could do this with people who disagree. She was tired, she said, of walking around her own town feeling misunderstood. Nobody asked her to give up what she believed. What changed was the invitation: someone asked real questions and listened.
Future Caucus’s Layla Zaidane shares the story of two young Oklahoma legislators who disagreed about abortion but had built a real relationship. By getting curious, they discovered a shared concern about mothers dying in their state—and passed a bipartisan bill together. And john a. powell of UC Berkeley’s Othering and Belonging Institute asks the question underneath it all: whose future are you helping to create?
The thread through it all: hope often begins with an experience. You show up, someone takes you seriously, and together you change something that matters. You don’t have to save the country by yourself, but you can become a builder by working on one relationship, one place, one chance to shape what happens next.
Key discussion points
Exhaustion isn’t apathy: Why people who care deeply step back from civic life, and how fewer people participating can leave the loudest voices shaping the conversation.
The perception gap: How Americans overestimate the other side’s extreme views—and often assume those people dislike them, too.
Politics as the hardest divide: Stephen Hawkins on why connecting across political differences feels harder than connecting across race, class, or religion, and what holds people back.
A more inviting way in: Why working on a shared local problem can feel more welcoming than starting with a conversation about what divides us, and why people want a process that treats them with dignity and shows their participation can make a difference, even when they don’t get the outcome they wanted.
Feeling worn out, feeling shut out: What local research reveals about unequal belonging, trust, and influence—and the assumptions people make about whose voice counts.
Who has a way in: How education, income, age, and race shape people’s connections to community life and their opportunities to influence local decisions.
An invitation worth accepting: John Sarrouf on the Rod and Gun Club member who arrived skeptical and left wanting to talk with people on the other side, and why connection and belonging can be stronger motivators than fear and animosity.
Whose future are we creating? john a. powell on the anxiety of a changing world and the invitation to help shape what comes next.
The relationship before the breakthrough: How two Oklahoma legislators found common cause on maternal health, and what their example offers teachers, parents, community leaders, and others who want to build together.
Practical takeaways
Give yourself room to rest. Taking a break from the news can protect your energy. But stepping away from community life altogether leaves the conversation to the loudest voices, so consider which relationships and parts of community life still feel worth staying connected to.
Check your picture of the other side. We often imagine people we disagree with holding more extreme views, and feeling more hostility toward us, than they actually do.
Start somewhere familiar. Your library, place of worship, kid’s soccer field, or the coffee shop where someone knows your name can offer a foothold. Invest a little more time there.
Widen the circle. Look for a small way to connect with someone whose experiences or beliefs differ from yours, perhaps through a place or activity you already enjoy.
Invite people into shared work. Give people a reason to come together around something they care about. The relationships they build can help them navigate harder conversations later.
Make the invitation feel different. People who expect a fight will stay away. Ask real questions, listen to the answers, and make it clear that no one has to give up what they believe to take part.
Ask who’s missing, and why. If you lead or organize, learn who feels shut out, what gets in the way, and what would make participation feel worthwhile.
Build relationships before you need them. Knowing someone beyond a position or disagreement can open possibilities when a difficult issue arises.
Make one meaningful contribution. Strengthen a relationship, support a local effort, or care for a place in your community. A manageable beginning can give you and someone else a reason to keep showing up.
Hosts
Nichole Argo is the Founder and Executive Director of TogetherUp Institute.
Scott Hutcheson is the Executive Director of E Pluribus Unum.
Produced by Next Chapter Podcasts.

Disclaimer
This podcast’s information is provided for general reference and was obtained from publicly accessible sources. The Podcast Collaborative neither produces nor verifies the content, accuracy, or suitability of this podcast. Views and opinions belong solely to the podcast creators and guests.
For a complete disclaimer, please see our Full Disclaimer on the archive page. The Podcast Collaborative bears no responsibility for the podcast’s themes, language, or overall content. Listener discretion is advised. Read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy for more details.