The Vulnerability Paradox

I’ve been struggling with the word “vulnerability” lately.

It’s become this gold standard in the online world. If you aren’t bleeding on the page, if you aren’t posting the crying selfie, if you aren’t giving a play-by-play of your burnout, are you even a creator? Just this morning I saw another “I almost quit” note, and two scrolls later the “3 months sober” one.

We seem to be obsessed with the idea of being “real,” but in our desperate sprint away from the polished, curated Instagram era, I think we’ve accidentally run into a different kind of ctrap.

We are now curating our disasters just as carefully as we used to curate our wins.

And to be honest, I don’t know where I fit in that spectrum anymore.

I sit here writing this with a newborn in my lap. My reality right now is objectively messy. There is a cold cup of coffee on a stack of unread mail. I am operating on fragmented sleep. There are days when I feel like I am holding my business together with duct tape and a prayer.

I could post about that every single day.

I could turn my sleep deprivation into content. I could package my anxiety into a hook. It would be “authentic.” It would be “relatable.” It would probably get a flood of comments telling me how brave I am.

But every time I go to write that post, my fingers freeze.

Not because I’m ashamed of the mess—I’m actually quite at peace with it—but because turning it into content feels like a betrayal of the moment.

It feels like a performance of imperfection.

And this is where the paradox begins for me.

The moment you share your struggle specifically to get a reaction, are you being vulnerable? Or are you just commoditizing your pain?

I realized that for a long time, I was confusing Processing with Leading.

Processing is when you are in the middle of the storm. You are wet, cold, and scared. When you scream for help in that moment, you are looking for validation. You are asking the audience to hold space for you.

Leading is when you have found the shelter. You dry off. You look back at the storm and you figure out how you survived it. Then, you walk back out to the edge of the rain to show others the way in.

One is a cry for help; the other is an act of service.

And I think we have confused the two.

We think that to be “authentic,” we have to invite 70,000 strangers into the storm with us. But I’m starting to believe that true authenticity—the kind that actually respects your audience—is doing the work in private so you can show up with clarity in public.

It’s the difference between sharing a wound and sharing a scar.

A wound is still bleeding. It needs attention. It triggers worry in the people watching you.A scar is healed. It’s proof of survival. It triggers trust.

I don’t want you to worry about me. I want you to trust that I can help you.

And perhaps that is why I have leaned so heavily into Systems this year.

It isn’t because I am a robot who loves spreadsheets.It is because the System is the only thing that allows me to be useful to you when I am a mess.

The system is my way of protecting you from my chaos.

It allows me to show up, deliver value, and help you build your own life, even when I am writing this with one hand and a baby on my chest.

To me, that is the quietest, most honest form of authenticity I can offer.

It isn’t about performing a perfect life, and it isn’t about performing a messy one.It is about Congruence.

It is about making sure that the person I am online is reliable enough to help the person you are offline.

I realized I don’t need to be “relatable” to be valuable.I don’t need to mirror your pain to validate it.

I just need to be steady.

So, if you’ve been feeling the pressure to bare your soul for the algorithm, or to perform a version of “messy” that feels just as exhausting as perfection… maybe you can just stop.

You don’t owe the internet your trauma.You just owe your audience your truth.

And sometimes, the truth is just: “I’m here. I’m working. And I figured out a way to make it easier. Here it is.”

I might do a Part 2 on the actual mechanics of this—how to technically distinguish between a “wound” post and a “scar” post when you are sitting at the keyboard drafting content.

But I felt like we needed to dismantle the pressure to perform first. This was the foundation.

Thanks for letting me think out loud.

Love,

Ana

This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit howwegrowtoday.substack.com/subscribe