Mystery Pie
Mystery Pie
Podcast Description
Welcome to Mystery Pie, where the bizarre becomes reality and the hidden is revealed. You're not crazy for what you've experienced, there are countless others who share your encounters but remain silent, afraid of ridicule. This podcast is a sanctuary for those fringe stories.We explore the unsettling: interdimensional travel, government coverups, military secrets, ancient technology, and conspiracies buried deep within society. These are the stories that nightmares are made of. In a world that has programmed us to forget ancient truths, we find ourselves trapped in a Darwinistic, materialistic age that has deliberately distanced us from the deeper realities of our existence.At Mystery Pie, we unravel the tangled web of deception, searching for answers in a supernatural realm filled with paranormal activity. Join us as we pray together, sharpening one another as remnant warriors standing against the darkness. We contemplate the feeling of homesickness for places we’ve never been and the longing for people we’ve never met, echoes of something lost but not forgotten.Until we find the answers, everything remains a mystery.
Podcast Insights
Content Themes
The podcast focuses on unsettling themes like interdimensional travel, government coverups, and paranormal activities, with episodes such as 'That's Not Our Mother You're Talking To,' exploring personal encounters with demons, and 'Don't Mess with Ouija Boards,' sharing cautionary tales about the supernatural, emphasizing spiritual battles and ancient truths.

Welcome to Mystery Pie, where the bizarre becomes reality and the hidden is revealed. You’re not crazy for what you’ve experienced, there are countless others who share your encounters but remain silent, afraid of ridicule. This podcast is a sanctuary for those fringe stories.
We explore the unsettling: interdimensional travel, government coverups, military secrets, ancient technology, and conspiracies buried deep within society. These are the stories that nightmares are made of. In a world that has programmed us to forget ancient truths, we find ourselves trapped in a Darwinistic, materialistic age that has deliberately distanced us from the deeper realities of our existence.
At Mystery Pie, we unravel the tangled web of deception, searching for answers in a supernatural realm filled with paranormal activity. Join us as we pray together, sharpening one another as remnant warriors standing against the darkness. We contemplate the feeling of homesickness for places we’ve never been and the longing for people we’ve never met, echoes of something lost but not forgotten.
Until we find the answers, everything remains a mystery.
Please stay up to date with us on our Instagram page.https://www.instagram.com/mysterypiepodcast?xtok=azM4eDZqYmJuY2Iw&utm_source=qr
What happens when a lifelong fascination with the dark, the paranormal, and the unexplained leads you into experiences you can’t forget?
On this episode of Mystery Pie, Evan joins us to share a deeply personal story that spans childhood paranormal encounters, shadow figures, sleep paralysis, unexplained orbs, and one unforgettable night when a massive black triangular craft appeared overhead. It was silent, dark, and close enough that he says he could have hit it with a slingshot.
But the strangest part of Evan’s story isn’t just what he saw. It’s where his journey eventually led.
Growing up fascinated by the macabre and spending years immersed in Detroit’s punk scene, Evan describes a period of searching, experimenting, and feeling increasingly disconnected from his faith. He shares the experiences that haunted him, the encounter that left him shaken, and the moment that began his journey back to Jesus Christ.
We also discuss the questions these experiences raise about the paranormal, spiritual deception, the unknown, and how our worldview shapes the way we interpret what we encounter.
We don’t claim to have every answer. We’re here to ask the questions, examine the stories, and explore the unknown through a biblical lens.
Have you experienced something you can’t explain? We want to hear your story.
📧 Email us at [email protected]
Join us for Evan’s remarkable journey from darkness and unanswered questions toward faith, hope, and a renewed relationship with Christ.
This is Mystery Pie—and there’s always another slice of the unknown.
Outro message by Jenjo.
Outro music by Slasher Dave
SUPPORT THE SHOW
Buzzsprout https://bit.ly/3m50hFT
Paypal http://bit.ly/3Gv3Zjp
Grubterra Dried Black Soldier Fly larvae are a healthy alternative to dried mealworms. Black Soldier Fly Larvae contain 75 times more calcium than mealworms and have the perfect calcium to phosphorus balance for chickens, turkeys, ducks, and pet birds. You're going to get stronger eggshells, healthier feathers, and a stronger ability to fight sickness due to Black soldier Fly antimicrobial benefits. Use discount code JESSE10 for 10% off the entire website!

Disclaimer
This podcast’s information is provided for general reference and was obtained from publicly accessible sources. The Podcast Collaborative neither produces nor verifies the content, accuracy, or suitability of this podcast. Views and opinions belong solely to the podcast creators and guests.
For a complete disclaimer, please see our Full Disclaimer on the archive page. The Podcast Collaborative bears no responsibility for the podcast’s themes, language, or overall content. Listener discretion is advised. Read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy for more details.