Informed Dissent
Informed Dissent
Podcast Description
You Have Permission to Question, Scrutinize, Push Back, and Dissent!
Ben Appel, Cori Cohn, Lisa Selin Davis, Eliza Mondegreen, and Jamie Reed report on their adventures and misadventures trying to explain and mitigate the gender culture wars. We will publish most weeks, focusing some on the news and some on important topics from social transition to lawsuits to what the heck the word “gender” means. informeddissentpodcast.substack.com
Podcast Insights
Content Themes
The podcast tackles crucial topics within the realm of gender culture, including social transition, legislative changes, and public perceptions of gender identity. Episodes explore current events, such as the implications of Trump’s executive orders on gender and the influence of protests and education on societal attitudes, with discussions often featuring critical reflections on news articles and media narratives.

You Have Permission to Question, Scrutinize, Push Back, and Dissent!
Jamie Reed, Cori Cohn, and Lauren Leggieri report on their adventures and misadventures trying to explain and mitigate the gender culture wars. We will publish most weeks, focusing some on the news and some on important topics from social transition to lawsuits to what the heck the word “gender” means.
Earlier this month, voters in Colorado, Nebraska, Arizona, and Washington weighed in on girls’ sports ballot initiatives. To make sense of what’s at stake, we turned to a philosopher who has spent five years examining the arguments for opening the female category to males, and finding that none of them hold up.
Jon Pike came to the philosophy of sport by an unusual route. He was a political philosopher who wrote his PhD on Marx and Aristotle, and an endurance athlete who raced at the World Triathlon Championships in Kona. A prescription for Ritalin, and a therapeutic use exemption, got him thinking about doping, and from there about cheating, fairness, and who sport is for.
In this conversation, Jon argues that sport is not merely a social construction. It has an essence: physical tasks that are difficult but not impossible, organized around real bodies. Separate competitions for males and females are how we honor women’s athletic achievement as equal in value to men’s. Jon takes on the Paralympic analogy, explains why more research into trans athletes won’t tell us anything useful, and makes a left-wing case for sex-based categories. He also explains why sport is the arena where ordinary people say, “but hang on a moment,” and why that moment matters for every other policy question that follows.
Jon Pike is Professor of Philosophy at the Open University, where he works on the philosophy of sport. His research covers fairness, eligibility and the justification of sex categories in sport. He has published widely on these questions in the Journal of the Philosophy of Sport and elsewhere, including work on transgender athletes and the essence of rugby, and on the difference between “meaningful” and fair competition. He has also co-authored policy work on biology, fairness and transgender athletes, and he contributes regularly to public debate about how sporting bodies and legislators should set eligibility rules.
* On X: @RunThinkWrite
* His forthcoming book, An Essentialist Theory of Sport, will be published by Routledge next year
Informed Dissent is produced by the LGB Courage Coalition, a registered US nonprofit funded entirely by small donations. We promote evidence-based medicine, work to end the medicalization of gender nonconformity, and advocate for LGB rights.
If this episode mattered to you, please comment, like, subscribe, and share it. Word of mouth is how independent shows survive. Reach us in the Substack comments, at [email protected], or through lgbcourage.org.
Stay informed. Stay ready to dissent.
This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit informeddissentpodcast.substack.com/subscribe

Disclaimer
This podcast’s information is provided for general reference and was obtained from publicly accessible sources. The Podcast Collaborative neither produces nor verifies the content, accuracy, or suitability of this podcast. Views and opinions belong solely to the podcast creators and guests.
For a complete disclaimer, please see our Full Disclaimer on the archive page. The Podcast Collaborative bears no responsibility for the podcast’s themes, language, or overall content. Listener discretion is advised. Read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy for more details.